Skip Navigation
Skip to contents

대한신장학회

My KSN 메뉴 열기

간행물 검색
Comparison of CT Volumetry vs Nuclear Renography to Predict Remaining Kidney Function After Uni-nephrectomy in Living Kidney Donors
Sang Hun Eum, Hanbi Lee, Hyuck Jin Cho, Chul Woo Yang, Byung Ha Chung
2021 ; 2021(1):
논문분류 :
춘계학술대회 초록집
Objective: CT volumetry and nuclear renography from 835 kidney donors were retrospectively included. We investigated correlation between sk-volume and sk-mGFR and the agreement of two modalities. Mismatch was defined as sk-volume higher and sk-mGFR smaller than the other kidney, or vice versa. We compared the predictive value for post-donation kidney function between two modalities in total group and in mismatched group. Based upon decision preference, we compared kidney function recovery between two modalities at 6 months after donation. Methods:  Mean baseline estimated GFR was 100.01ml/min/1.73m2. The mean right and left sk-volume were 171.18 and 179.71cm3 and mean right and left sk-mGFR were 53.72 and 53.44ml/min, respectively. 701(83.96%) donated left kidney. Sk-mGFR and sk-volume showed significant correlation(r=0.484, P<0.001) and the results showed significant agreement in Bland-Altman plot and Intraclass correlation coefficient was 0.647(P<0.001). In total group, CT volumetry was superior to nuclear renography in predicting kidney function after donation(1 month: βCT=0.402, P<0.001, βrenography=0.242, P<0.001; 6 months: βCT=0.448, P<0.001, βrenography=0.214, P<0.001) by multivariable linear regression analysis. In mismatched group(326 donors), CT volumetry still outweighed nuclear renography(1 month: βCT=0.453, P<0.001, βrenography=0.259, P<0.001; 6 months: βCT=0.480, P<0.001, βrenography=0.285, P<0.001). When mismatch occured, 260(79.75%) procurements were decided by nuclear renography. Functional recovery was higher in CT volumetry preferred group, although it did not reach statistical significance(33.99% vs 30.09%, P=0.098). Results: CT volumetry was appropriate to assess single kidney function and it outperformed nuclear renography in predicting kidney function after donation. Therefore, when contradictory results between left and right kidney occur, CT volumetry can be preferred in procurement strategy. Conclusions: Objective: Computed tomography(CT) and nuclear renography are performed to decide kidney procurement. The aim of this study was to compare single kidney(sk) function and single kidney(sk) volume in predicting post-donation kidney function. Further, we aimed to investigate which modality is more predictable for functional recovery, especially when the results were contradictory. Methods: CT volumetry and nuclear renography from 835 kidney donors were retrospectively included. We investigated correlation between sk-volume and sk-mGFR and the agreement of two modalities. Mismatch was defined as sk-volume higher and sk-mGFR smaller than the other kidney, or vice versa. We compared the predictive value for post-donation kidney function between two modalities in total group and in mismatched group. Based upon decision preference, we compared kidney function recovery between two modalities at 6 months after donation. Results:  Mean baseline estimated GFR was 100.01ml/min/1.73m2. The mean right and left sk-volume were 171.18 and 179.71cm3 and mean right and left sk-mGFR were 53.72 and 53.44ml/min, respectively. 701(83.96%) donated left kidney. Sk-mGFR and sk-volume showed significant correlation(r=0.484, P<0.001) and the results showed significant agreement in Bland-Altman plot and Intraclass correlation coefficient was 0.647(P<0.001). In total group, CT volumetry was superior to nuclear renography in predicting kidney function after donation(1 month: βCT=0.402, P<0.001, βrenography=0.242, P<0.001; 6 months: βCT=0.448, P<0.001, βrenography=0.214, P<0.001) by multivariable linear regression analysis. In mismatched group(326 donors), CT volumetry still outweighed nuclear renography(1 month: βCT=0.453, P<0.001, βrenography=0.259, P<0.001; 6 months: βCT=0.480, P<0.001, βrenography=0.285, P<0.001). When mismatch occured, 260(79.75%) procurements were decided by nuclear renography. Functional recovery was higher in CT volumetry preferred group, although it did not reach statistical significance(33.99% vs 30.09%, P=0.098). Conclusions: CT volumetry was appropriate to assess single kidney function and it outperformed nuclear renography in predicting kidney function after donation. Therefore, when contradictory results between left and right kidney occur, CT volumetry can be preferred in procurement strategy.
위로가기

(06022) 서울시 강남구 압구정로 30길 23 미승빌딩 301호

Copyright© 대한신장학회. All rights reserved.